Dave Rennie is set to confirm a 44-man All Blacks squad on Monday for Rugby's Greatest Rivalry tour to South Africa — and the selection battle for the final ten spots is generating real debate among Kiwi rugby insiders. New Zealand Herald correspondent Liam Napier has laid out his expectations for who joins the 34 already locked in from the July international window, and the choices Rennie faces are anything but straightforward.
Prop Selection Battle in All Blacks Squad
Up front, Napier tips Hurricanes prop Siale Lauaki as a potential bolter. His size, ball-carrying ability and recent switch to loosehead make him an intriguing option. With Tamaiti Williams unavailable, Chiefs loosehead Ollie Norris is expected to provide cover in the front row. At hooker, George Bell is tipped to return as backup, while Fabian Holland should slot in as a sixth lock alongside Jamie Hannah, who continues his development in the absence of the injured Scott Barrett.
Loose Forward Strategy and Forward-Back Split
The loose forward selection is where the real tactical puzzle lies. Napier argues it hinges on whether Rennie opts for a 6-4 or 7-3 forward-back split — a decision that could define how the All Blacks approach the physical demands of playing in South Africa. His read is that Highlanders breakout star Lucas Casey offers greater long-term upside than the more experienced Du Plessis Kirifi, even if that is a bold call given what's at stake.
In the halves, Napier backs Noah Hotham's inclusion on the strength of his running threat at halfback. Out wide, Rieko Ioane's versatility across centre and wing earns him a recall in this projection, with Timoci Tavatavanawai offering physical difference despite pace concerns. With Caleb Tangitau and Leicester Fainga'anuku both facing injury doubts, the back-three picture is thin. Emoni Narawa is identified as the most likely addition, fitness permitting.
